As if I didn’t have enough challeges in daily life right now, I have also been battling an issue with my hens.
Oh, I’m thrilled to report they are finally laying! I estimate that about 7-9 are laying regularly, as we get 5-7 eggs every day now, with 6 most days. I suspect I know who isn’t laying, as we never see them in the nest boxes.
Except at night. Which leads me to my latest battle. You see, hens are supposed to use the nest box ONLY for laying an egg. As a result, that means the nest box stays nice and clean for the egg, and the egg doesn’t get contaminated with chicken poo. However, when they roost (sleep), they poop right where they are, making a big mess–including when they roost in the nest box. I was having to rinse my eggs every day. I tried the old “go out after roost time and shoo the hens out of the boxes” trick, but it wasn’t working. Every day I was finding messy eggs, and it was causing more work as I tried to keep the boxes clean, which in turn cost more money in the nest bedding (usually a mix of hay and straw).
Plan A, the original coop design, was comfy nest boxes and shooing the roosting hens out. It didn’t work. The worst of the problem was hens roosting on the outer lip of the box, with their tail ends hanging into the nest, thereby leaving a mess along the front edge in the morning.
So we tried Plan B….S cut some port holes out of a piece of scrap wood, and I hoped that darkening up the box would help prevent some roosting. S also added a new roost along the front, both to allow the bigger hens to easily enter the tiny holes, and to provide another option for roosting.
It didn’t work. In fact, the hens went from roosting on the outer lip to just going inside the nest entirely, making the entire nest messy. Sometimes, 2 or even 3 would share a nest. So, this weekend, I resorted to Plan C…stapling strips of fabric across the port holes, to create a completely isolated nest box.

BINGO! As of 2 days later, my nest boxes are still clean! Not a single hen has been caught roosting, and not a single pile of manure has been deposited in a nest box. My eggs are clean, which means I don’t have to wash them, which means they are able to keep their naturally protective coating on the shell to keep germs out. We’ll see if it lasts, but it seems the roosting hens still wanted to be able to see their coop-mates. With the fabric in place, they can’t see, so their security is taken away (or at least that’s my theory). On the other hand, the layers want to be as secluded as possible, so they appreciate the darkened, more private boxes.
After further research, it seems the root of my problem is that my nest boxes are not located correctly. Apparently, they need to be located sufficiently away from the roosts, and lower than the middle-level roost if they can’t be seperated significantly. As you can see in my first photo, my boxes are located directly adjacent to my roosts (with some roosts actually touching the boxes), and at the same level as the most popular roosts. Therefore, when the higher roosts fill up with hens, the remaining hens were content to roost on the boxes rather than perch on the lower roosts.
As a final note, should you find yourself using this final technique, the hens were not thrilled about the change to their boxes when I added the fabric. So, I pulled the 2 middle pieces out of the way of the opening (I just tucked them up out of the way), which allowed the hens to more easily see the other side. Then, I took a few hens, and placed them inside the boxes, to find their own way out. Within a few hours, I had my normal number of eggs. That evening, I allowed the 2 tucked up strips to fall back down, completely closing off the hole. The following day, it didn’t seem to bother the girls at all.



January 23, 2012 at 10:27 pm
You might also try leaving golf balls in the nesting boxes all the time, too. I’ve seen it where people have little doors that they slide across at night to prevent them from getting in there entirely.
But ya, they should be lower than the roost, because they like being higher up to sleep. {knock on wood} We have not had any issues with anyone trying to sleep in the nesting boxes. And ours are good about doing their eggs IN the nesting box. Now, if we could get them all to LAY DOWN to let loose of their eggs instead of standing and dropping them, we’d really have it made.
Thank goodness for hard shells!
January 23, 2012 at 10:46 pm
Oh, they always lay their eggs in the nest boxes (thankfully, that has NOT been a problem!). Some were just roosting there as well, causing the eggs to get mucked up. Hopefully, we have solved the problem!
January 24, 2012 at 4:41 pm
I’ve heard (but have not personally tested) that if you leave the golf balls in there, it “reminds” them of what the boxes are for and therefore disinclines them to try to sleep on the lumps…. you’ll have to let me know if you try this and what the results are.
January 24, 2012 at 6:50 pm
We actually have been using wooden eggs from the beginning–1 in each nest box. Works the same..the “remind” them where it is safe to lay. In any case, I noticed the hens actively laying will pull the egg up underneath herself to protect it for the time she is sitting there. The roosting hens, however, just push it to the side. Interestingly, the roosting hens are also the one I suspect are not yet laying, so perhaps their nurturing instinct just hasn’t kicked in yet? I guess time will tell.
January 24, 2012 at 12:47 pm
This is awesome! I cut some 5-gal buckets in half and used them to cover my nest boxes, but they still hang out in the opening. I’m stealing this idea – very cool… Thanks!
January 26, 2012 at 4:02 am
I need to do some reworking because even though my boxes are lower they still roost on them and mess in it badly… Good Job! On figuring it out!